I was not a huge fan of this game. I played it, and liked it, but there was something about it that just didnt appeal to me. I guess my only gripe is that some of the puzzles had illogical, and sometimes had odd answers. Why wouldnt this game make my top 25? Simply because the games that last on me are ones that make an impact on me, and I cant truthfully say that I would be glorifying this title say... five/ten years from now Regardless, I can still tell that it is an excellently designed game for any gamer and can respect why so many are in awe with it.