Graphics 10/10--You'll either love em or hate em. As for me I thought the graphics were beautiful for being cell shaded, a few of my friends say they hate the graphics in this game so either you will love it or hate it deal. Pretty much it looks like you're playing in a cartoon, lucious colors, cartoony looking characters and all that other work. I really cant find one single flaw in the graphics on this game, sure the game is cartoony looking but imo that is what makes it even better, it seperates itself from other games.
Gameplay 9/10--It depends, the gameplay can be rated higher or lower. The main game itself is fairly easy but on the other hand there are ton of collectibles to get so if you are a gamer who likes searching for everything in a game you will think this game is perfect, however if you are a gamer who plays a game once and says thats enough then you mite not rate the game that high in gameplay. Basically you are Link the kid in this game, after seeing your sister get captured you start on your journey to fight Ganondorf and stop his evil. Im pretty sure everyone knows the story of Zelda so I shouldnt need to explain much, to put it plain and simple you must stopp Ganondorf from spreading his evil across the world, on your journey you will encounter a few bosses and many friends that you will need to remember to finish the game.
Replayability 9/10--Depends if you want to do side quests and collect all the items, if you do that then you will love this game, if not you will still like the game but not get the full potential the game has
Bottom Line--Zelda WindWaker is no surprise, a well developed game that carrys tons of fun for all people of all ages. Sure it may be easy but thats what replayability is for, go back and get all the collectibles. Its a must buy the Cube owners.