Baldurs gate might have gotten a 10 from me, if it was based around the PC system of fighting and teams and such, but i still give it a solid 9 for its great RPGish sorta Action oriented ways.
The graphics were nice in terms of a console, nice a crisp, although some weapons looked basically the same to me.
The depth of the game was a pretty poor, you cant customize your characters, choose different classes or different races (besides the three already set out for you) although not a big deal, but it would have been nice to set my own kind of character instead of the pre-generated ones.
this game does diserve the 9 however, although its relatively short, it will still keep you entertained with the hard mode you have to unlock (that is actually really hard!!)