Let me say this first: the plot of ED is second to none. The writers did an incredible job. Also, the inclusion of characters and settings from so many different time periods was stunning. However, the game had some serious flaws for me. While the graphics for the player characters were good, the monsters looked almost cartoonish, kind of ruining the tension. Also, I have seen better graphics on the GC. The sound was second to none. The ambient noise is incredible, and somewhat makes up for the dulled down creep factor caused by the graphics. If you want a good story, and moderately challenging gameplay, ED may be your ticket.