First I'll give the details on the graphics. It seems like the graphics were rushed a bit, as I don't see a big difference from previous similar titles on ps2 and Dreamcast. However, the animations are great, and don't seem really repetitive.
Score= 7.5
Now,the sound and gameplay. The sound is mediocre, with color analyst John Madden sounding good, but the play by play guy drones on likes he's drugged or something Score= 6
Gameplay is solid, with a good practice mode, fun "madden cards" and a great franchise mode. Score= 9