I can honestly say i've enjoyed MoH: Pacific Assault more.
it tries to be a tactical shooter, but you cannot lean left or right. it tries to be a realistic shooter, but having a big RED CIRCLE above each enemy kinda takes away from the realism, eh? it tries to make it strategic, but there is one clear path to follow. it feels like one of those amusement park rides where you walk down a path, and out of window pops out enemy. the gunshot sound is horrible. the voice acting is cheezy, especially the corny lines being used "look at this place, how can a place be so beautiful and so deadly at same time?" or other teammate starts reciting peotry his dad read to him. i feel like i'm in charge of a team of pansies.
wow, what strategy. (add sarcasm). see red circle. shoot randomly in general direction, until circle is grey. approach a bit closer. repeat. eventually, you kill the red circle (err, i mean soldier). no point aiming or going for head shots, as all you can do is make circle turn from red to grey.
i can't believe all the 90% scores. you can tell its been quite dry since HL2 was released, and any new game, no matter how LAME, gets big praise.