Gameplay:
Not only is the game terribly easy, but its really short. The AI is terrible. I can't remember ever dying in this game. There are 3 ships to play as, but all are uninteresting, basically because they don't have any variety except in outer appearance. The level designs are bland and boring. The action was sparse as well. Nothing overly intense at all.
Graphics:
For a first generation PS2 game, they are good, but I have seen better in the first games. With stuff graphically amazing at the the time (like The Bouncer and Ico), Starfighter looks alright at best.
Sound:
Bad voice acting and music don't make up for the decent sound effects. But every Star Wars game will have at least decent sound effects, since the effects are all the sounds ripped directly from the movies.
Replay:
None. I beat this game and returned it before it was due back. That anxious to get it back to Blockbuster.
Overall:
Pass on it. Even a fan of the series can see past the Star Wars theme and notice the crappy interface that they call a Star Wars game.