March Madness 2004 doesn't do much in the way of innovating the game or being accessible to newbies, but those already obsessed with college ball should find it more than enjoyable.
March Madness is essentially a diehard college basketball title for diehard fans of such games. The casual fan need not apply, as the controls are complex and not easily mastered. Those who can look past the intense learning curve will find a very intense sim-heavy control scheme that allows for almost limitless defensive and offensive possibilities.
Though the gameplay is top-notch for those willing to put some time into the game, March Madness 2004 has some serious presentation problems, beginning with the audio – it's not the college fight songs and sound effects that give me the problem, those are excellent - it's the hideously annoying announcing job by Dickie Vitale. Five minutes of him shouting out the most cliché of clichés will have you hitting the mute button.
Madness 04 also lags behind the competition in the visual arena. Though it looks adequate in all areas, the picky fan looking for accurate player models will be sorely disappointed. The courts look shiny and pretty, though the crowd is of the "cardboard cutout" variety.
Chances are, however, if you're looking for a top-notch, simulation style college basketball game, you're not overly concerned with petty production details. If you're hardcore enough about simulation gameplay as to look past a few glaring flaws (including a weak dynasty mode), you'll enjoy your semester with March Madness.
-George